| * | New York won coin toss and elected to receive. |
First Quarter |
New York Jets (15:00) Michaels kick 2 yards into end zone Christy 25 return (Hawkins). |
| NYJ 23 | 1–10 | Snell 3 run left tackle (Shinnick). |
| NYJ 26 | 2–7 | Snell 9 run left tackle (Volk). |
| NYJ 35 | 1–10 | Boozer run right end loss of 4 (Shinnick). |
| NYJ 31 | 2–14 | Namath 9 pass to Snell (Boyd). |
| NYJ 40 | 3–5 | Snell draw middle loss of 2 (Miller). |
| NYJ 38 | 4–7 | Johnson 44 punt to B 18. Play nullified and Baltimore penalized 5 for offsides. |
| NYJ 43 | 4–2 | Johnson 39 punt Brown 9 return (McAdams). |
Baltimore Colts (10:55) |
| BAL 27 | 1–10 | Morrall 19 pass to Mackey (Elliott). |
| BAL 46 | 1–10 | Matte 10 sweep right (Baker). |
| NYJ 44 | 1–10 | J. Hill 7 sweep left (Hudson). |
| NYJ 37 | 2–3 | Matte 1 run left (Elliott). |
| NYJ 36 | 3–2 | J. Hill 5 run right tackle (Baird). |
| NYJ 31 | 1–10 | J. Hill run right loss of 3 (Philbin). |
| NYJ 34 | 2–13 | Morrall pass to Orr underthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 34 | 3–13 | Morrall 15 pass to Mitchell (Baird). |
| NYJ 19 | 1–10 | Morrall pass to Richardson dropped. |
| NYJ 19 | 2–10 | Morrall pass to Mitchell overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 19 | 3–10 | Morrall run evading rush no gain (Atkinson). |
| NYJ 19 | 4–10 | Michaels’s 27–yard field–goal attempt was wide right no good. |
New York Jets (5:33) |
| NYJ 20 | 1–10 | Namath pass to Snell dropped. |
| NYJ 20 | 2–10 | Namath 2 pass to Lammons (Lyles). |
| NYJ 22 | 3–8 | Namath 13 pass to Mathis (Gaubatz). |
| NYJ 35 | 1–10 | Namath pass to Maynard overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 35 | 2–10 | Namath 6 pass to Sauer (Lyles). |
| NYJ 41 | 3–4 | Namath pass to Sauer overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 41 | 4–4 | Johnson 38 punt Brown 21 return (Snell). |
Baltimore Colts (3:05) |
| BAL 42 | 1–10 | Morrall pass to Mackey dropped incomplete. |
| BAL 42 | 2–10 | J. Hill 3 run middle (Elliott). |
| BAL 45 | 3–7 | Morrall pass to Richardson broken up (Sample). |
| BAL 45 | 4–7 | Lee 51 punt downed at NY 4. |
New York Jets (1:58) |
| NYJ 4 | 1–10 | Snell 4 run right tackle (Shinnick). |
| NYJ 8 | 2–6 | Snell 5 draw right (Gaubatz). |
| NYJ 13 | 3–1 | Namath 3 pass to Sauer left (Lyles) fumbled Porter recovered for Baltimore at NY 12. |
Baltimore Colts (:14) |
| NYJ 12 | 1–10 | J. Hill run left tackle loss of 1 (Philbin). |
END OF FIRST QUARTER:
Baltimore 0 New York 0 |
Second Quarter |
| NYJ 13 | 2–11 | Matte 7 sweep left (Beverly). |
| NYJ 6 | 3–4 | Morrall pass to Mitchell off his shoulder pad and intercepted in end zone Beverly no return touchback. |
New York Jets (14:09) |
| NYJ 20 | 1–10 | Snell 1 run left tackle (Braase). |
| NYJ 21 | 2–9 | Snell 7 run left tackle (Shinnick). |
| NYJ 28 | 3–2 | Snell 6 run left end (Lyles). |
| NYJ 34 | 1–10 | Snell 12 draw left end (Lyles). |
| NYJ 46 | 1–10 | Namath pass to Sauer broken up (Shinnick) incomplete. |
| NYJ 46 | 2–10 | Namath 6 pass to Mathis (Bubba Smith). |
| BAL 48 | 3–4 | Namath 14 pass to Sauer (Lyles). |
| BAL 34 | 1–10 | Namath 11 pass to Sauer (Volk). |
| BAL 23 | 1–10 | Boozer 2 run right (Shinnick). |
| BAL 21 | 2–8 | Namath 12 pass to Snell (Gaubatz). |
| BAL 9 | 1–goal | Snell 5 run right tackle (B.R. Smith). |
| BAL 4 | 2–goal | Snell 4 run over left tackle touchdown (9:03). J. Turner kicked extra point. |
New York scoring drive: 80 yards 12 plays 5:06.
New York 7 Baltimore 0 |
Baltimore Colts (9:03) Johnson kick to B 2 Pearson 26 return (Richards). |
| BAL 28 | 1–10 | Morrall pass to Richardson overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 28 | 2–10 | Morrall 30 pass to Matte (Hudson). |
| NYJ 42 | 1–10 | J. Hill 4 run right tackle (Atkinson). |
| NYJ 38 | 2–6 | Matte run right no gain (Biggs). |
| NYJ 38 | 3–6 | Morrall pass to Mackey broken up (Sample) incomplete. |
| NYJ 38 | 4–6 | Michaels’s 46–yard field–goal attempt was no good. |
New York Jets (6:37) |
| NYJ 20 | 1–10 | Boozer 1 run right (Logan). |
| NYJ 21 | 2–9 | Namath 35 pass to Sauer (Lyles). |
| BAL 44 | 1–10 | Snell 9 run left (Gaubatz). |
| BAL 35 | 2–1 | Snell 3 run middle (Shinnick). |
| BAL 32 | 1–10 | Namath pass to Maynard overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 32 | 2–10 | Namath pass to B. Turner underthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 32 | 3–10 | Namath sacked loss of 2 (Gaubatz). |
| BAL 34 | 4–12 | J. Turner’s 41–yard field–goal attempt was no good. |
Baltimore Colts (4:13) |
| BAL 20 | 1–10 | Morrall 6 pass to Richardson (Sample). |
| BAL 26 | 2–4 | Matte 58 run around right end (Baird). |
| NYJ 16 | 1–10 | J. Hill 1 run left tackle (Atkinson Hudson). |
| NYJ 15 | 2–9 | Morrall pass to Richardson intercepted at NY 2 Sample no return. Two–Minute Warning. |
New York Jets (2:00) |
| NYJ 2 | 1–10 | Snell 2 run left (Shinnick). |
| NYJ 4 | 2–8 | Snell 3 run left tackle (Miller). |
| NYJ 7 | 3–5 | Snell draw left no gain (Bubba Smith). |
| NYJ 7 | 4–5 | Johnson 32 punt Brown fair catch. Play nullified by offsetting penalties illegal procedure against New York and roughing the kicker against Baltimore. |
| NYJ 7 | 4–5 | Johnson 39 punt Brown 4 return (Neidert). |
Baltimore Colts (:43) |
| NYJ 42 | 1–10 | Morrall 1 pass to J. Hill (Crane). |
| NYJ 41 | 2–9 | Matte lateraled back to Morrall Morrall pass to J. Hill middle intercepted at NY 12 Hudson 9 return to NY 21 as time expired. |
END OF SECOND QUARTER:
New York 7 Baltimore 0 |
Third Quarter |
| Johnson kick to goal line Brown 25 return (Smolinski). |
| BAL 25 | 1–10 | Matte 8 run fumbled Baker recovered for New York at B 33. |
New York Jets (14:25) |
| BAL 33 | 1–10 | Boozer 8 run left (Volk). |
| BAL 25 | 2–2 | Snell 4 run right (Bubba Smith). |
| BAL 21 | 1–10 | Boozer 2 run left (Curtis). |
| BAL 19 | 2–8 | Namath 5 pass to Snell (Curtis). |
| BAL 14 | 3–3 | Snell 3 run right (Gaubatz). |
| BAL 11 | 1–10 | Boozer run left end loss of 5 (Lyles). |
| BAL 16 | 2–15 | Namath sacked loss of 9 (Bubba Smith). |
| BAL 25 | 3–24 | Namath pass to Lammons broken up (Logan) incomplete. |
| BAL 25 | 4–24 | J. Turner 32–yard field goal (10:08). |
New York scoring drive: 8 yards 8 plays 4:17.
New York 10 Baltimore 0. |
Baltimore Colts (10:08) Johnson kick to B 5 Brown 21 return (D’Amato). |
| BAL 26 | 1–10 | Morralll pass to Mackey overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 26 | 2–10 | Morrall pass to J. Hill no gain (Grantham). |
| BAL 26 | 3–10 | Morrall run evading rush loss of 2 (McAdams). |
| BAL 24 | 4–12 | Lee 44 punt Baird no return (S. Williams). |
New York Jets (8:04) |
| NYJ 32 | 1–10 | Namath 1 pass to Mathis (Curtis). |
| NYJ 33 | 2–9 | Namath 14 pass to Sauer (Volk). |
| NYJ 47 | 1–10 | Namath pass to Maynard overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 47 | 2–10 | Boozer 4 run left (B.R. Smith). |
| BAL 49 | 3–6 | Namath 11 pass to Lammons (Logan). |
| BAL 38 | 1–10 | Namath pass to Maynard overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 38 | 2–10 | Namath 14 pass to Snell (Curtis). |
| BAL 24 | 1–10 | Mathis 1 draw middle (Shinnick). |
| BAL 23 | 2–9 | Namath pass to Maynard incomplete. Namath hurt. |
| BAL 23 | 3–9 | Parilli pass to Sauer underthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 23 | 4–9 | J. Turner 30–yard field goal (3:58). |
New York scoring drive: 45 yards 10 plays 4:06.
New York 13 Baltimore 0 |
Baltimore Colts (3:58) Johnson kick hit goal post touchback. |
| BAL 20 | 1–10 | Matte 5 sweep right (Baker). |
| BAL 25 | 2–5 | Unitas pass to Matte no gain (Grantham). |
| BAL 25 | 3–5 | Unitas pass to Orr dropped incomplete. |
| BAL 25 | 4–5 | Lee 38 punt Baird fair catch. |
New York Jets (2:24) |
| NYJ 37 | 1–10 | Snell 3 run left (B.R. Smith). |
| NYJ 40 | 2–7 | Namath pass to Sauer overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 40 | 3–7 | Namath 11 pass to Sauer (Lyles). |
| BAL 49 | 1–10 | Namath 39 pass to Sauer (Lyles). |
| BAL 10 | 1–goal | Snell 4 run right tackle (Gaubatz). |
END OF THIRD QUARTER:
New York 13 Baltimore 0 |
Fourth Quarter |
| BAL 6 | 2–goal | Snell 3 run left tackle. Play nullified and Baltimore penalized 3 (half the distance) for offsides. |
| BAL 3 | 2–goal | Snell run left no gain (Volk). |
| BAL 3 | 3–goal | Mathis 1 run left (Gaubatz). |
| BAL 2 | 4–goal | J. Turner 9–yard field goal (13:26). |
New York scoring drive: 61 yards 7 plays 3:58.
New York 16 Baltimore 0 |
Baltimore Colts (13:26) Johnson kick 6 yards into end zone Pearson 33 return (Richards). |
| BAL 27 | 1–10 | Unitas 5 pass to Mackey (Grantham). |
| BAL 32 | 2–5 | Matte 7 sweep right (Baker). |
| BAL 39 | 1–10 | Unitas 5 pass to Richardson (Sample). |
| BAL 44 | 2–5 | Matte 19 run left (Hudson). |
| NYJ 37 | 1–10 | J. Hill 12 run right tackle (Baird). |
| NYJ 25 | 1–10 | Unitas pass to Richardson overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 25 | 2–10 | Unitas pass to Orr deep intercepted in end zone Beverly no return touchback. |
New York Jets (11:06) |
| NYJ 20 | 1–10 | Boozer 2 draw middle (Miller). |
| NYJ 22 | 2–8 | Snell 2 run left (Porter). |
| NYJ 24 | 3–6 | Boozer 7 sweep left (Gaubatz). |
| NYJ 31 | 1–10 | Snell 10 run left (Curtis). Baltimore penalized 15 for personal foul. |
| BAL 44 | 1–10 | Snell 7 run middle (Bubba Smith). |
| BAL 37 | 2–3 | Boozer 2 run right tackle (B.R. Smith). |
| BAL 35 | 3–1 | Mathis run left tackle no gain (Michaels). |
| BAL 35 | 4–1 | J. Turner’s 42–yard field–goal attempt was no good. |
Baltimore Colts (6:34) |
| BAL 20 | 1–10 | Unitas pass to Mackey broken up (Grantham) incomplete. |
| BAL 20 | 2–10 | Unitas pass to Richardson overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 20 | 3–10 | Unitas pass to Mackey overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 20 | 4–10 | Unitas 17 pass to Orr (Beverly). |
| BAL 37 | 1–10 | Unitas pass to Richardson overthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 37 | 2–10 | Unitas pass to J. Hill underthrown incomplete. |
| BAL 37 | 3–10 | Unitas 11 pass to Mackey (Baird). New York penalized 15 for personal foul. |
| NYJ 37 | 1–10 | Matte 1 run left (Biggs). |
| NYJ 36 | 2–9 | Unitas 21 pass to Richardson (Sample). |
| NYJ 15 | 1–10 | Unitas pass to Matte overthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 15 | 2–10 | Unitas 11 pass to Orr (Beverly). |
| NYJ 4 | 1-goal | NY penalized 2 (half the distance) for offsides. |
| NYJ 2 | 1–goal | Matte run left no gain. Play nullified and New York penalized 1 (half the distance) for offsides. |
| NYJ 1 | 1–goal | Unitas keeper middle no gain (Biggs). |
| NYJ 1 | 2–goal | Matte run right no gain (Atkinson). |
| NYJ 1 | 3–goal | Hill 1 run over left tackle touchdown (3:19). Michaels kicked extra point. |
Baltimore scoring drive: 80 yards 14 plays 3:15.
New York 16 Baltimore 7 |
New York Jets (3:19) Michaels onside kick Mitchell recovered for Baltimore at NY 44. |
Baltimore Colts (3:14) |
| NYJ 44 | 1–10 | Unitas 6 pass to Richardson (Sample). |
| NYJ 38 | 2–4 | Unitas 14 pass to Orr (Beverly). |
| NYJ 24 | 1–10 | Unitas 5 pass to Richarson (out of bounds). |
| NYJ 19 | 2–5 | Unitas pass to Richardson broken up (Sample) incomplete. |
| NYJ 19 | 3–5 | Unitas pass to Orr underthrown incomplete. |
| NYJ 19 | 4–5 | Unitas pass to Orr overthrown incomplete. |
New York Jets (2:21) |
| NYJ 20 | 1–10 | Snell 1 run right (Bubba Smith). Baltimore–first time out. |
| NYJ 21 | 2–9 | Snell 6 run right (Logan). Two–Minute Warning. |
| NYJ 27 | 3–3 | Snell 4 run right (Gaubatz). Baltimore–second time out (1:54). |
| NYJ 31 | 1–10 | Snell 2 run right tackle (Boyd). |
| NYJ 33 | 2–8 | New York penalized 5 for delay of game. |
| NYJ 28 | 2–13 | Snell 1 run right (B.R. Smith). |
| NYJ 29 | 3–12 | New York penalized 5 for delay of game. |
| NYJ 24 | 3–17 | Snell 3 sweep left (Austin). Baltimore–third time out (:15) |
| NYJ 27 | 4–14 | Johnson 39 punt Brown no return out of bounds. |
Baltimore Colts (:08) |
| BAL 34 | 1–10 | Unitas pass to Richardson incomplete. |
| BAL 34 | 2–10 | Unitas 15 pass to Richardson (Sample). |
FINAL SCORE:
New York 16 Baltimore 7 |
FINAL RECORDS:
New York 13–3 Baltimore 15–2 |